12 JUL 2019

No Deal is a disaster for local farmers. I won't be voting to destroy local businesses

The National Farmers' Union (NFU) has said that a No Deal Brexit is the worst possible deal for the farming industry.

The Food and Drink Federation (FDF) has called it a "grisly prospect".

No Deal would lead to bankruptcies and shortages hitting local businesses and consumers alike. The UK has a trade deficit in food, drink and animal feed products with both the EU and with non-EU countries.

The UK imported £46 billion of food products in 2018, 70% of which were from the EU. These imports are necessary because we are not and have no prospect of being self-sufficient in feeding our nation. We are currently 61% self-sufficient in all foods and only 75% sufficient in foods that can be grown here. Whilst we can source food further afield than the EU, our rapid supply chains for fresh produce from our nearest and most important trading partners will inevitably face disruption, especially so if there is a bad tempered exit alongside threats to renege on international commitments.

As it stands, EU farm subsidies to the UK currently make up around 50-80% of farm income. The CAP currently provides nearly £4billion of support annually to farmers across the UK as well as providing a market safety net. There is a serious question mark over whether the Government will continue to offer this support in the long term after Brexit and, if our economy takes a hit even close to the levels predicted, we are unlikely to be able to afford these as well as the host of other commitments that the leadership candidates have signed up to. Something will have to give but these costs have not been properly set out by those claiming No Deal will be pain free.

The government has assured the industry that all rules and processes, regarding farm payments, will remain the same until the Agriculture Bill is introduced in to the UK Parliament but farmers are understandably anxious about the long term.

They are even more worried about the short-term impact of a No Deal scenario because WTO tariffs will immediately be applied for EU trade, as well as WTO rules for plant and animal health checks.

These will have major impacts on both import and export markets, consumer choice, the speed of supply chains, and prices.

Tariffs are usually higher for agricultural products than for other goods and services and perishable products such as fish and meat from local producers are very sensitive to delays at borders. Without an alternative arrangement, the EU will treat the UK as a third country and a range of tariffs as well as costly checks, registrations and certifications will start to apply for the first time and these costs will leave many local businesses unable to compete.

Agriculture is also impacted by the no deal effects of other policies e.g. immigration (for seasonal, agri-food workers and vets).

If the UK wishes to sign Free Trade Agreements with non-EU countries such as the USA, we may be required to alter standards and accept intensively reared animals which have been fed hormones or antibiotics as growth promoters or whose carcasses have been treated with products like chlorine.

I know there are some MPs who feel all this is a price worth paying for Brexit, but this is easier to insist on when their own livelihoods are not at stake. I won't be voting to put local farmers out of business, to risk lower food standards or to have completely avoidable shortages and higher prices.


Wollaston is an utter disgrace. I voted for a Tory MP and have been robbed. When is the by-election? Cretins like Wollaston have brought politicians into contempt.
- George, Paignton

I'm sorry that George of Paignton feels like this, and his dismissive words about Dr Wollaston - who gives serious reasons for her decisions - does nothing to help his cause.
- Robert Lawson-Peebles

You were elected because you represented the Conservative party, and accepted the job on that basis, you are paid a substantial sum plus many benefits to do that role, when you decided to leave the Conservative party and go “Independent “ then Liberal” the honest and decent thing for you to do was to hold a by-election. But no ,Sarah hangs on to he benefits and over generous pension, I believe in 2011 you sponsored a bill that called for any MP who resigns from their Party, to be required to hold a by-election, like most things doesn’t apply to you. As far as I and many other constituents are concerned you are receiving the tax payers money under false pretences . Your very keen on changing the rules as often you change your mind. You want a 2nd Referendum, let your constituents have theirs by way of a by-election.
- Peter Paignton

Sadly Sarah now lives in a bubble as can be observed that at every interview it is I, I, I, with no concern for the people that elected her. It is not enough to say you're working for your constituents best interests whilst ignoring them. Seems like a case of 'doctor knows best !
- John

Well here we are again, witnessing double standards from pro remain MPs that have used every opportunity parliamentary procedure offers them to thwart the democratically expressed will of the people to LEAVE the EU. Now we hear them shouting foul because we have a Prime Minister and a Goverment that is using parliamentary procedure to DELIVER what the public voted for! Boris Johnson and the current Goverment are the real Democrats in parliament. The rest, including Sarah I'm sorry to say, are abusing their position to try and override the democratically expressed will of the people and they CANNOT be allowed to get away with that any longer. Boris and the Goverment have my full support.
- David H

Dear George of Paignton (although I doubt you are really called George or that you live in paignton) Please take your Brexit party bile elsewhere. You contribute nothing to the debate.
- Bob

Is Paignton is Sarah Wollaston's constituency? There seem to be negative comments from there which should perhaps be directed elsewhere?
- Ruth

Ruth, of course part of Paignton is in Woolastons constituency, I unfortunately voted for her, or rather the Conservative Party, still a Conservative. Your comment shows the level of your political knowledge, and bias.
- peter paignton tq33xu

The NFU have also said that they are VERY HAPPY with the Withdrawal Agreement that Boris Johnson has negotiated, yet you do not support that either. In fact the NFU spokesman for Devon said that Boris' WA delivers the best possible options for the farming community as we exit the EU. What ARE you supporting this week, besides Remain and Extinction Rebellion - it certainly isn't respecting 17.4 million people or the health of democracy in this country - because you most definitely DO NOT represent the farming community.
- Elizabeth Graham

Post a comment

Back to all posts